avatar
Warner Brown

A Map of China, By Stereotype

finalbaidumap
[This image may not be reproduced without permission from Foreign Policy.]

Why is the northwestern Chinese region of Xinjiang “so chaotic?” Why are many from the southern metropolis of Shanghai “unfit to lead”? And do people from central Henan Province really steal manhole covers? These are just some of the questions — ranging from the provocative, to the offensive, to the downright ridiculous — that Chinese people ask about themselves and each other on Baidu, the country’s top search engine, which says it processes about 5 billion queries each day.

In the West, amateur sociologists use Google’s voluminous search history to finish half-written questions about different regions. They then plot the stereotypes onto maps such as this one of the United States, which The Atlantic called “The U.S. According to Autocomplete.” China, with its long history of regional stereotyping, is ripe for similar treatment. After all, it is home to 22 provinces, five autonomous regions, four municipalities, as well as Taiwan, what some there would call a renegade province, pictured above because of its prevalence on Baidu. Held together by a common history and culture (and occasionally force), the regions are divided by real and perceived differences in wealth, environment, stability, ethnicity, and personality — not to mention variations in that history and culture. Chinese society has deep schisms, one of which came into devastating relief on March 1, when a terror attack on a Kunming train station resulted in 33 deaths and 143 injuries. Chinese authorities have attributed the attacks to separatists from Xinjiang.

Studying China’s collective online subconscious via auto-complete requires flexibility. Results change over time, so readers may not be able to replicate results with fealty. But even allowing for these caveats, online queries about China’s regions are revealing, and they have a particularly sharp edge where they concern peripheral regions whose restive local populations sustain independence movements of varying intensity. Below is a list of common questions netizens pose about Xinjiang, a region of 22 million whose roughly 10 million ethnic Uighur Muslim minority lives alongside Han Chinese in a state of tension that frequently erupts into violence:

Others also wonder why Xinjiang’s Turkic Uighur minorities look like foreigners, and why they hate the Han Chinese, who make up roughly 92 percent of China’s total population but less than 50 percent in Xinjiang. Meanwhile, Tibet — also home to simmering discontent with Chinese rule — produces no auto-completed results at all. The same is true for its neighbor Qinghai, which sits on the Tibetan plateau and has a large ethnic Tibetan population. (Deleting the leading “why” from queries about Tibet produces many auto-completed results, mostly about travel tips and historical television dramas set in the region.)

Netizens associate several northern regions with varying degrees of violence. Liaoning, Jilin, and Heilongjiang — collectively called the Northeast — are famous for their Siberian winters as well as their beautiful women, but the apparently pugnacious locals are also known for starting fights. Inner Mongolia calls to mind the brutal December 2013 hazing of newly recruited firefighters, and the tiny region of Ningxia’s sole result concerns the grisly murder of a family of seven following a marital spat in October 2013.

One of the starkest patterns involves queries into the omnipresent divide between China’s rich coastal provinces and poor inland ones. Netizens appear envious of wealthy Jiangsu and Zhejiang, asking why they are so developed and rich. China’s wealthiest province, Guangdong, is curiously considered “chaotic” in addition to “developed,” while the moderately wealthy Fujian is seen as a “poor” coastal underperformer.

One might expect Beijing and Shanghai to impress for their comparative wealth and modernity, but the general gloom of netizen queries hints at disappointed expectations. Those researching Shanghai seem particularly interested in the city’s lack of public heating, a service provided throughout northern China but denied elsewhere. Meanwhile, searches for “smog” crowd the list of results for Beijing, not surprising given the city’s frequent bouts with choking pollution.

Seven inland regions are associated with terms like “poor,” “backward,” and “undeveloped,” with none coming off worse than Henan. Perhaps it’s because of that province’s roughly 100 million residents supposed penchant for stealing manhole covers, however inaccurate or distorted that picture may be:

A case can be made that the dismal repute of Henan and other poor inland regions derives from modern China’s society of mass migration, which puts people of vastly unequal regions side-by-side in big cities and creates conditions for new stereotypes to form and old ones to spread. Many migrants are second-class citizens in all but name, scorned by local residents, consigned to working menial jobs, and often associated with rising crime and other social ills. The dislike can be mutual — several queries about Shanghai ask why the “exclusive” natives look down on outsiders. One common question asks simply why Shanghai people hate Anhui people, many of whom come to seek their fortunes in the coastal metropolis.

Not all queries are so severe. Many revolve around physical appearance; netizens ask why Shandong people are so tall and why Sichuanese are short and have good skin. The top result for Hubei concerns “nine-headed birds” — not a reference to local fauna, but an ancient mythical creature that has since become a sometimes-derogatory nickname for allegedly crafty locals. Users also ask why the people of Shanxi love vinegar, and why those in Sichuan and Hunan eat chili peppers. The adventurous, simian-craving dining habits of Guangdong attract particular attention. Most regions also feature searches related to local history: All of Shaanxi’s results revolve around nicknames from its time as the cradle of Chinese civilization.

Baidu’s name, which means “hundreds of times,” was inspired by an 800-year-old Song Dynasty poem about the persistent search for an ideal beauty in the midst of chaos. Those Chinese using the search engine are surely looking for reliable information in a chaotic Chinese Internet. But for outsiders looking to understand how China views itself, Baidu’s auto-completed questions are at least as illuminating as its answers.

14 Comments
Jump To Comments
avatar

Warner Brown

Warner Brown is a frequent contributor to Tea Leaf Nation. He is based in Shanghai.
  • poisson

    Wow…this is the type of article you would write for high school extra credit.

  • Ezra Lee

    well, Taiwan shouldn’t have been included in this map……

  • Dave

    Hilarious … but true. These are quite often the stereotypes I hear about the Chinese provinces.

  • Shengfeng Wang

    If you always think about negative issues, of course you can make it like this. Also, you can make similar map for the U.S. There is no country is perfect. For another thing, Chinese gov just has just established for no more than 80 yrs. You should require a 10-year-old kid to learn how to drive a plane. They’ve develop crazily. It is a miracle.

    • poisson

      65 years. Not even a lifetime.

      • mr.wiener

        A Chinese lifetime.

    • ex-expat

      Why are Chinese so god damn defensive all the time? This is what other Chinese people wrote about their own country, can you read? Also, a map with the same thing about the US is in the article….CAN YOU READ? And why does every Chinese person mention the US when something about China is mentioned? You guys are really pathetic sometimes.

      • poisson

        We were taught to think that way by the govt. An attack on China or the govt is a vicarious attack on the self. I have to say it was well implemented.

        • ex-expat

          What a horrible quality. Nobody attacked anything or anybody…Jesus

          • poisson

            Not everyone thinks the way you do. It’s not hard to understand.

      • saf

        Because it’s so natural to conflate an individual identity with a collective one and take things personally?

        Therefore, if ONE (presumably) Chinese poster gets a bit defensive it’s natural to conclude that EVERY Chinese person suffers from such inveterate complexes, which compel his/her invoking the USA at every available opportunity. Is it not?

    • ClausRasmussen

      >> Also, you can make similar map for the U.S

      As the article mention, someone _did_ make a similar map for the US. Here: http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/01/why-is-pennsylvania-so-haunted-the-us-according-to-autocomplete/283356/

  • pregret

    Shandong = Tall. Yes. Female footballers.

  • Okiku Ningyo

    Taiwan is not china!
    台湾不是中国!