avatar
David Wertime

Chinese Netizens To Government: Don't Back Down From Philippines

Exercises in the South China Sea

There’s no love lost between China and its American-allied neighbor, the Philippines. The two have been at odds for a month since tensions arose in the reputedly oil-rich Scarborough Shoal (in Chinese, the Huangyan Islands, or 黄岩岛) on April 8, when Chinese vessels blocked a Philippine warship from arresting Chinese fishing boats near the disputed islands in the South China Sea. Even before this latest incident, Chinese netizens were incensed in 2010 after Philippine police completely botched a raid intended to free hostages on a Hong Kong tour bus in Manila, leading to eight Chinese casualties.

The Philippines belongs to who, again?

In recent days, matters have gotten worse. Just yesterday, CCTV host He Jia (@cctv和佳) was compelled to apologize on Sina Weibo, China’s Twitter, for her “slip of the tongue” after saying on air that the Philippines itself (as opposed to the Scarborough Shoal) was “an intrinsic part of China’s territory.” “A mistake happened that absolutely should not have happened,” a very contrite Ms. He wrote. “Every minute and every second the responsibility of a broadcast host is extremely heavy, and from now on I will redouble my efforts and be more conscientious.” 

The near-groveling tone of Ms. He’s apology suggested it was ordered by authorities wary of further stirring up angry sentiment toward China’s neighbor, sentiment which could turn against China’s government should it fail to act. If that is the case, they were right to worry. Commenting by the thousands, netizens made clear they felt no apology was necessary, instead expressing wide support for Ms. He’s “mistake.” @帅翼柏 wrote, “Everyone supports you, whichever non-patriotic leaders punish you should prepare to suffer a netizen crusade.” @消极等待 added, “your slip of the tongue stated many people’s heartfelt wishes.” “Don’t apologize,” @杂牌史军 exhorted, “the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) needs you!” 

No love for the Foreign Ministry

Indeed, China’s MFA has not exactly won the hearts of netizens. MFA spokesperson Hong Lei said at a recent press conference (Chinese) that “China has undisputed sovereign claim to the Yuangyan Islands [i.e. the  Scarborough Shoal]. No matter what the Philippines says or does, it still cannot change this fact. It would be strange indeed to submit the sovereign territory of a country to arbitration [as some have suggested]!” 

Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei got a nasty reception online

But this talk was not nearly tough enough for most commenters, many of whom responded angrily (if also hilariously). @商报阿甘 echoed a common trope: “This must be the most patient ministry in history…[Let's say] someone runs into your house and sleeps with your wife. You can say: ‘No matter what she says, or does, it still does not change the fact that so-and-so is my wife.” @我是有文化有素质不耍流氓的流氓 wrote, “‘No matter what…still…’ is a structure everyone learns in elementary school.” 

Vice Foreign Minister Wu Ying’s recent warning that China was prepared to respond to “any escalation” seems to have garnered a more positive online response, but it alone may not be enough to placate the blogosphere. @小城bye邓丽君 complained that peaceful responses have “led to more and more disputed islands.” 

Netizens to government: Harden up

Other commenters wrapped themselves in the flag. Their nationalist statements might normally compel one to doubt whether they were in fact government-sponsored “fifty-cent” posters. But they directed such vitriol at their leaders that one can only assume they were sincere (and unpaid), calling them “incapable,” impotent,” and “cowardly.” Most felt that the MFA was simply paying lip service to the problem, hoping it somehow went away. “Go ahead, delay,” @我爱在黄昏 wrote, “and pass the hot potato to [presumptive next leader] Xi [Jinping].”

Indeed, many netizens accused government officials of being too busy jockeying for internal position to attend to China’s national security. This is a stinging charge. Many Chinese believe that internal instability during World War II–when the Communists and Nationalists were still vying for control of China–rendered their country vulnerable to Japanese invasion and occupation. “The history of humiliation continues,” wrote @背影2003. @厉小帅 added, “If the transfer of power delays and prevents a government from defending its own sovereign territory, [everyone] should just ‘leave the stage [下台],’” slang for being booted from office. “The elders are all busy jockeying for position,” @杜雷思 observed, “so who is going to manage this little matter.”

It also doesn’t help that China’s Defense Minister Liang Guanglie is currently out of town, visiting the Pentagon. Although he may be busy complaining (half-heartedly) about U.S. arms sales to Taiwan, that means he is not in situ and ready to manage a conflict should one arise, or should public opinion require it. Netizens were keen to this fact too. “No rush,” @特里_LY wrote sarcastically, “wait until Secretary Liang returns from visiting the U.S. and we can discuss later.”

He Jia apologized profusely for her "slip of the tongue"

The Philippines may indeed sense an opening. One Philippine expert seems to have made matters in the blogosphere worse by observing in a recent article what is likely true: China “does not dare to send troops to the South China Sea,” not only because China’s nearest base is over 1,000 nautical miles away from the would-be conflict zone, but because China is currently undergoing “a very delicate period with the change of government.” China, he predicted, would fold if the Philippines maintained a resolute stance (Chinese).

What’s next?

So how far will tensions truly escalate? Does war truly lie on the horizon? Netizens hazarded widely differing guesses. @胡老丫儿 wrote confidently, “It’s 99% likely [China] won’t strike.” Two minutes later, @十年一斗米 wrote just as confidently, “[They've] gone for the face, it’s not possible not to strike.” @老啄阿东 argued that 80% of Chinese citizens supported military action against the Philippines, and “as the party in power, the Communist Party…will definitely strike [given] this…public support.” 

Predicting the future, of course, is a loser’s game, even if we at TLN are reasonably skilled at it. It’s clear what would transpire if netizens had their way. But China’s government likely views itself as needing to manage internal public opinion, showing enough resolve to forfend charges of being soft or inattentive, but enough flexibility to stave off an armed conflict at a fragile time. One can only hope they act for the long-term peace of the region, and not simply to jump out of friendly fire’s way.

23 Comments
Jump To Comments
avatar

David Wertime

David is the co-founder and co-editor of Tea Leaf Nation. He first encountered China as a Peace Corps Volunteer in 2001 and has lived and worked in Fuling, Chongqing, Beijing, and Hong Kong. He is a ChinaFile fellow at the Asia Society and an associate fellow at the Truman National Security Project.
  • Pingback: Hao Hao Report

  • Jaycasey

    Are Chinese Netizens aware of how much closer Scarborough Shoals is to the Philippines than to China?  Have they seen a map?

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/OX7YCC4QBT5UBPVB5ACRE2UKWU CJeryackim

       Yes they have. That map had nine dashes on it.

    • Dong2x2000

      …there eyes are too small to see reality how close the island to the Philippines…or they are just blinded by their greed.

  • Jaycasey

    Are Chinese Netizens aware of how much closer Scarborough Shoals is to the Philippines than to China?  Have they seen a map?

    • CJeryackim

       Yes they have. That map had nine dashes on it.

    • Dong2x2000

      …there eyes are too small to see reality how close the island to the Philippines…or they are just blinded by their greed.

  • Pingback: Asia Unbound » China-Philippines Hacking War: A Missed Opportunity for Beijing?

  • Pingback: South China Sea Spat goes Cyber | Thandel inc. - We do

  • WhatIsMineIsMine

    China has own the Shoal since 1729.  To tell the Chinese to give it up is like telling  the British to give up the Falkland Island because it’s more closer to Argentina than Britain.

    • Dong2x2000

      …Philippines had the shoal as far as history can remember. Filipinos are fishermen too and had been fishing the in the shoal for who knows how long….chinese are driven by their greed…they don’t know how to feed their own population so they ended up grabbing territories from their neighbors.

  • WhatIsMineIsMine

    China has own the Shoal since 1729.  To tell the Chinese to give it up is like telling  the British to give up the Falkland Island because it’s more closer to Argentina than Britain.

    • Dong2x2000

      …Philippines had the shoal as far as history can remember. Filipinos are fishermen too and had been fishing the in the shoal for who knows how long….chinese are driven by their greed…they don’t know how to feed their own population so they ended up grabbing territories from their neighbors.

    • Larry

      That is a dumb argument. the Falklands belong to Britian in the first place. China has no clamim on the tiny rock where is a lot of oil in the area. china thinks they can bully all smaller countries around. to me China is pure evil. It is the country that is stated in Revelations called the “Kings of the East”. In end times they will take over all the countries because the United state will lose is position in the world. Poor poor Philippines. Brother you must get to the Bible now or you will lose your life after Christ calls His Church away which will happen any time.

      • eeeee

        Uh…seriously?

  • Dong2x2000

    china’s greed is as big as its population and land area…china is known to kill its own people, don’t ever think about doing that to the Filipinos you commies.  china will sooner fall in its own weight.

  • Dong2x2000

    china’s greed is as big as its population and land area…china is known to kill its own people, don’t ever think about doing that to the Filipinos you commies.  china will sooner fall in its own weight.

  • Radiokkmo

    I guess China needs to learn math.  This little rock in the South China sea is well  within 250 mile limit from the Philippines.  China thinks they can just bully this small nation.  Well the Unites States needs to stand behind her friends like the Philippines.  

  • Radiokkmo

    I guess China needs to learn math.  This little rock in the South China sea is well  within 250 mile limit from the Philippines.  China thinks they can just bully this small nation.  Well the Unites States needs to stand behind her friends like the Philippines.  

  • Kevs

    The Chinese have not looked back in their history. They despised the Japanese Demons that nearly annihilated them during WW2. Now they themselves have become the Japanese Demons. The new imperialists are rising and these people have no morals. Shame.

  • Kevs

    The Chinese have not looked back in their history. They despised the Japanese Demons that nearly annihilated them during WW2. Now they themselves have become the Japanese Demons. The new imperialists are rising and these people have no morals. Shame.

  • Larry

    That is a dumb argument. the Falklands belong to Britian in the first place. China has no clamim on the tiny rock where is a lot of oil in the area. china thinks they can bully all smaller countries around. to me China is pure evil. It is the country that is stated in Revelations called the “Kings of the East”. In end times they will take over all the countries because the United state will lose is position in the world. Poor poor Philippines. Brother you must get to the Bible now or you will lose your life after Christ calls His Church away which will happen any time.

  • eeeee

    Uh…seriously?